Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Happy New (Rules) Year!

Dr. Robin Farran’s is one of the USGA’s top Rules Officials who used to teach Advanced Rules at the Golf Academy of America in Phoenix. But now that all of the Golf Academies nationwide have suddenly closed, Dr. Farran is turning his attention to 2019. Says Dr. Farran, “It will assist our individual preparation for PGA/USGA Workshops and readiness for 2019 tournaments if we search the 2019 Rules for all relevant references as we consider the correct rulings.” In this month’s Diary of a USGA Rules Official, Dr. Farran continues his all-out push to educate us on/ahead of the most extensive changes to the Rules of Golf since 1984. New rulings are highlighted in red: Incident Reports Incident 1 In stroke play, as Player A putts from the fringe, Player B, another player in the group, lifts the flagstick that had been removed and placed on the putting green some distance from the hole. Due to the slope of the putting green, Player A’s ball could have reached the original location of the flagstick. **There is no penalty. A removed flagstick may be moved. See Exception to Rule 11.3. Incident 2 In four-ball stroke play, as Player C putts from the fringe, Player D, Player C’s partner, marks and lifts his ball on the putting green. Due to the slope of the putting green, Player C’s ball could have reached the location of Player D’s ball. **There is no penalty. A ball at rest on the putting green may be picked up when a ball is in motion. See Exception to Rule 11.3. Incident 3 Player K chips his or her ball up a slope towards the putting green. The ball lands short of the putting green and, as the ball rolls down the slope, Player K picks up his or her club that lay on the ground that could have affected where the ball would come to rest. **There is no penalty. When a ball is in motion, equipment may be moved. See Exception to Rule 11.3. Incident 4 Player J chips his or her ball up a slope towards the putting green. The ball lands short of the putting green and, as the ball rolls down the slope, Player J picks up a bunker rake that lay on the ground that could have affected where the ball would come to rest. **Player J gets the general penalty for a breach of Rule 11.3 in situations where Player J is aware that the ball is rolling towards the rake and the purpose of the lifting is to avoid the ball being deflected by the rake. See Rule 11.3 and Interpretation 11.3/1. True or False? 1. Player A’s caddie, without any verbal authorization, marks and lifts Player A’s ball which had come to rest on the putting green. This is permitted by the 2019 Rules. True                      False **See Rule 10.3b(1) and note the Exception in Rule 14.1b 2. In single match play, Player B mistakenly marks and lifts Player A’s ball on the putting green. Player B incurs a penalty of one stroke. True                       False **See Exception 2 under Rule 9.5b 3. In four-ball stroke play, Player A and Player B are partners. During a search for Player A’s ball in the rough, Player B accidentally moves Player A’s ball. Player B replaces the ball on the original spot, estimating the location in the rough. Player A is penalized one stroke for his or her partner’s actions. True                       False **No penalty is incurred. See Exception 2 under Rule 9.4b and Rule 23.5 4. In four-ball stroke play, Player A and Player B are partners. In taking relief from a penalty area, Player A drops the ball in the relief area not in the right way. Player B lifts the ball and drops the ball in the right way; the ball is dropped from knee height, lands in and comes to rest in the relief area. Player A incurs a penalty of one stroke for an incorrect procedure in addition to a one-stroke penalty for relief from the penalty area. True                       False **No penalty is incurred for Player B’s actions. See Rules 14.5a, 14.3b and 14.3c, and Rule 23.5 5. Player A’s tee shot is in a fairway bunker. Player A enters a nearby bunker and makes several practice swings touching the sand prior to returning to play his or her stroke from the fairway bunker. Player A is not penalized. True                      False **See Rule 12.2b(1) – 2nd bullet refers to the bunker. 6. Player B’s approach shot lands in a high-faced bunker adjacent to the putting green. As Player B enters the bunker, Player B strikes the sand with disgust over his previous shot. In match play, Player B incurs a loss-of-hole penalty. True                       False **See Rule 12.2b(2) – 6th bullet. 7. Player C’s ball is in a bunker embedded in the sand in a clearly unplayable location. Player C elects to proceed under Rule 19.2. Player C lifts his or her original ball and drops another ball outside the bunker on the line behind the location of the original ball and the flagstick. The ball lands close to the line and rolls and comes to rest about two feet behind where it landed. Player C played the ball and completed the hole. Player C incurs the general penalty for playing from a wrong place. True                       False **See Rule 19.3b and Rule 14.3c – two penalty strokes. Player C was permitted to proceed under any of the options for a ball unplayable including the procedure for Rule 19.3. 8. Player D’s ball is embedded in the dirt face of a bunker. Electing to proceed under Rule 19.2, Player D lifts the ball and drops the ball outside the bunker on the line behind the location of the original ball and the flagstick. The ball lands close to the line and rolls and comes to rest about two feet behind where it landed. Player D played the ball and completed the hole. Player D incurred a penalty of one stroke in stroke play or match play. True                      False **See Definition of “Bunker” and Rule 19.2b – the ball was not in the bunker. 9. Player A

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Happy New (Rules) Year! Read More »

Book Review: The Scoring Zone

I think writing a golf instruction book nowadays would be really difficult. I’m not saying I’ll never attempt the feat, but here’s the thing – the golf swing has remained relatively unchanged over the years, and there’s virtually nothing new to write about. What you have to do these days is take what’s already been written, and find a way to repackage it, say it in a different way, or find a new way of saying the same thing. The best golf instructors in the world already do this. They’re masters at repeating the same concepts to their students in different ways. What may resonate with one may fall on deaf ears with another. It happens all the time. But when Todd Sones published his 3rd book, The Scoring Zone, earlier this year, it wasn’t long before it found its way into my Cart on Amazon. I have a lot of respect for Todd, and he’s someone I’ve looked up to for a long time. I’ve posted several articles about his teaching philosophies on my blog. He’s also the guy I largely credit for convincing me to enroll at the Golf Academy of America in the winter of 2015. I first read about Todd in the January 2012 issue of Golf Magazine. I struggled to make putts early in my golfing career and came across his article, “Belly vs. Short,” after having switched to a belly putter. The very next month, I got fitted for one of Todd’s Coutour-brand belly putters. I made more putts with that than I had with any other flat stick up to that point in my life! Then in October of 2014, I was fortunate enough to be able to visit Todd in person at White Deer Run Golf Club for a private putting lesson. It was an experience I will never forget. It was at that session that Todd suggested I come out to hear him speak during his annual campus visit to the Golf Academy in Phoenix, and the rest is history. I decided to enroll not long after that. Todd is on the Golf Academy’s National Advisory Board, and with good reason. Todd is a Golf Digest Top 50 and Golf Magazine Top 100 Instructor who is really considered a putting guru for having worked with Tour players such as Luke Donald, Scott McCarron, Joe Durant, Steve Jones (1996 U.S. Open Champion), Shaun Micheel (2003 PGA Champion), and Hilary Lunke (2003 U.S. Women’s Open Champion), but he’s also carved out a nice niche for himself as one of the industry’s top short game experts. His half and full-day Scoring Zone Schools, which anyone can register for online at toddsones.com, range in price from $295 t0 $495, and I can tell you that there are rarely any open spots come class time. They always fill up very quickly! The Scoring Zone centers around four short game shots from 85-yards out to the edge of the green for the “average handicap player.” These shots are: the mini-wedge, the pinch shot or low trap, the high slider, and bunker play. Allow me to translate. In other words: approach shots, chip shots, pitch shots, and bunker shots. But those terms don’t sell golf instruction books anymore. Todd is also big on the concept of “standing to the handle.” I would say it’s the core tenet of his short game principles. He says you can use the club to “guide you into an ideal setup position — one that gets the club in the right position to make good contact with the ball and the ground while also keeping your spine in a neutral position.” Here’s how Todd describes the process later in the book: “The butt of the club should be pointing up right between your arms into the middle of your chest — just barely forward of the buttons on your shirt — when the club is soled on the ground. From a neutral, center, ball position, the club will then be the guide you need to set the face aimed at your target, your feet set in relation to the clubhead, your shoulders level, and your chest and spine neutral and in-line with what you’ve established with the club.” Stand to the Handle (STH) is the one concept Todd hopes his readers take away from this book. For a pinch (chip) shot, the handle leans slightly towards the target to de-loft the club and to get the ball to come out low and running. For a high slider or bunker shot, the handle is vertical or leaning slightly away from the target to add loft and encourage a higher-trajectory shot. In either case, you set your body so that the handle is pointing at the center of your sternum. That sets the ball position almost automatically. Here’s Todd demonstrating Stand to the Handle: There are two ideas in this book that I really like. The first is Todd’s suggestion to take your grip with your club out in front of you, your arms extended to about waist height, and the clubhead off the ground. “With your grip centered in front of you,” says Todd, “you should be able to look down and see the V’s created by your thumbs and index fingers pointing at your right shoulder.” I love this idea because it also helps you see two knuckles on your left hand (for a right-handed golfer), which is a neutral grip. Todd adds that, “By setting your grip this way, you’re preserving the natural up-and-down lever in your wrists so that they work the way they should on the various short game shots.” The lead wrist should hinge up-and-down in the same motion you would use if you were hammering a nail. The second thing I like is a drill called The Stork Drill. It’s the best drill in the book by far, and it helps a player to lead the downswing with the clubhead while finishing on the lead leg. It works

Book Review: The Scoring Zone Read More »