Blog

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Now What?

After a brief hiatus (having a newborn son will do that to you), one of my favorite segments is back! It’s called Diary of a USGA Rules Official, and it’s a by-product of Dr. Robin Farran. Dr. Farran teaches Advanced Rules at the Golf Academy of America in Phoenix and is one of the USGA’s top Rules Officials. The man helps write the book! Several times each month, Dr. Farran emails out different Rules scenarios and anecdotes as well as actual rulings. In this month’s installment, the good doctor is back with a few clarifications for us: Is the Player’s Original Ball Lost? 1. Player A’s second shot from the fairway might be lost or out of bounds.  Player A goes forward to the search area, then returns to where the previous shot was played after informing fellow-competitors that he will go back and play a provisional ball.  After another ball is dropped and played, a fellow-competitor calls to Player A informing him that his original ball has been found. The five-minute search-time has not expired. ** Player A must continue play with the substituted ball. Player A is not permitted to play a provisional ball after searching for his original ball. Although the substituted ball was dropped under an inapplicable Rule, when Player A played the dropped ball, the original ball became a “lost ball”. The Committee must determine an applicable Rule which would be Rule 27-1a.  See Decision 27-2a/1.5 and Decision 34-3/6. Item “e” in the Definition of “Lost Ball” is also relevant. 2. Player B’s second shot from the fairway might be lost or out of bounds.  Player B goes forward to the search area, then returns to where the previous shot was played after informing fellow-competitors that he will go back and play a provisional ball.  After another ball is dropped, a fellow-competitor calls to Player B informing him that his original ball has been found. The five-minute search-time has not expired. **The ball was dropped under an inapplicable Rule.  Player B is not permitted to play a provisional ball after searching for his original ball. Player B may pick up (or abandon) the dropped ball under Rule 20-6 and continue play with the original ball. See Decision 27-2a/1.5.  Decision 26-1/3.7 provides some insight to a player dropping a ball under an inapplicable Rule. 3. Player C’s ball heads towards a LWH.  Player C thinks his ball could be/may be in the LWH, makes an estimate of where the ball entered the hazard and drops a substituted ball. Player C then sees his original ball outside the hazard in a playable location. **Player C’s original ball is Player C’s ball in play. The dropped ball was not dropped under an applicable Rule. There was not virtual certainty that the original ball was in the LWH. Rule 20-6, the “eraser Rule”, permits Player C to lift the dropped ball (or abandon the dropped ball) and proceed correctly by continuing play with the original ball. See Decision 26-1/3.7. Score for Hole #X? On a par-3 hole, Player A’s tee shot heads left towards a lateral water hazard near the green. Player A announces his intent to play a provisional ball, stating that the ball might be in the hazard but might be in the bushes or trees outside the hazard. Player B, a fellow-competitor, states that he thinks the ball is probably in the hazard. Player A’s provisional ball comes to rest just short of the green. Player A, without searching for his original ball or having any discussions with the fellow-competitors, picks up the provisional ball and drops the ball adjacent to the lateral water hazard and completes the hole in 4 additional strokes. At Scoring, an official is brought in to rule on the incident at the request of Player B. **Player A was entitled to play a provisional ball since Player A believed that his original ball might be in the hazard but also might be lost outside the hazard – see Rule 27-2a and Decision 27-2a/2.5. Player A is not required to search for his original ball and there is no certainty that the original ball is in the lateral water hazard. When Player A lifted the provisional ball, the ball in play due to the original ball not being found or the location known to be in the lateral water hazard, Player A incurred a one-stroke penalty for a breach of Rule 18-2. When the ball was not replaced, Player A incurred the general penalty for a breach of Rule 18, but not the one-stroke penalty – see the Penalty Statement under Rule 18 (when a player incurs the general penalty for a breach of Rule 18, there is no additional penalty under Rule 18). Player A lay 3 with the provisional ball, a two-stroke penalty under Rule 18 for lifting his ball in play and playing from a wrong place. Player A then played 4 additional strokes with his ball to complete the hole for a total score of 9. [In match play, Player A would lose the hole for playing from a wrong place; general penalty for a breach of Rule 18.] Scoring in Four Ball The format in the following incidents is four-ball stroke play. Unless noted otherwise, each score card was signed by both players and a marker and no penalty strokes affected the accuracy of the recorded scores. 1. The score card returned for Side A/B has a 3 for Player A and a 4 for Player B on hole #6. Prior to the close of competition, it was determined that Player A scored 4 on hole #6. **Side A/B is disqualified. The score to count, Player A’s recorded score of 3, was lower than Player A’s correct score of 4.  2. The score card returned for Side C/D has a 3 for Player C and a 4 for Player D on hole #8. Prior to the close of competition, it was determined that Player D scored 5 on hole #8. **The score for Player C was correct. The score for Player D does not affect Side C/D’s score for the

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Now What? Read More »

PGA Level 2 Seminar: Day 5

How’s this for a “good morning?” Erik Nielsen (PGA) came to the front of the ballroom first thing this morning and suggested we check-in for our Saturday morning flights right away. My return flight takes me back through Dallas-Forth Worth (DFW), and Hurricane Harvey just happens to be a bearing down on the Texas coast. Great! I can’t help but think back to my return trip last year and the problems I had getting out of Port St. Lucie. My flight got cancelled in the middle of the night, and because my phone was on vibrate and charging on the other side of the room, I didn’t hear the calls or the emails pouring in. I woke up to two cancelled flights and a real mess on my hands to try and get home. Not good. And just when I was going to say, “We made it to the last day!” Now, we may never leave. Hopefully our flights tomorrow won’t be delayed or even cancelled like they were last year at this time. Two of our classmates already had to leave early, missing the latter part of the afternoon session, so they could hopefully get home and beat the storm. Would you rather be home in a hurricane or would you rather be stuck at the Hilton Garden Inn? I’m not so sure. For the second day in a row (a carbon copy of yesterday as a matter of fact), we started the day outside because there was rain in the forecast in the afternoon. I love starting our teaching days outside not just because it’s a little cooler in the mornings but because it also gives us a little more perspective heading into the afternoon slide shows. In my PGA Education survey, I suggested they do that for every Seminar session. It gets the day off to a great start! Brad Brewer (PGA) opened the day’s festivities by demonstrating another short game lesson, but this time instead of driving, he taught putting. I was amazed at how little Brad actually said to the four students with whom he was working. He told us later that it was by design. He wanted to encourage more self-discovery, something we discussed in Thursday’s afternoon session. Then Rafael took over with a session on pitching. He went over three different wrist activities: none to none, some to none, and some to some. Each of the activities represents a different amount of wrist hinge in the back and forward swings. It’s a method of teaching that never occurred to me, but I loved it! It’s a great way to describe the different pitch shots, their different trajectories, and their different chances for success. I’m definitely going to incorporate this methodology into my teaching back home, especially with my junior golfers. They’ll love it too! Then, while one half of the group headed over to the Club Lab with Rafael Floriani (PGA), we broke into groups of four or five and each one of us actually had to conduct a group lesson in front of our classmates. Brad walked around to give us feedback and even made a few suggestions. When it was time to switch, we went into the Lab and watched a video on changing an iron shaft. We also measured shaft length and swing weight and got to see how to use a loft and lie machine to check both measurements. Again, for me, much of this was a review of what I had already learned at the Golf Academy. That education has really come in handy at both the Level 1 and now the Level 2 Seminars. After lunch we started talking about augmented feedback, drills, and training aids. Over the last couple of days, I wish Brad had shared some more stories about what it was like working for and with Arnold Palmer at Bay Hill for ten years. Sadly, it was a lot of PowerPoint slide reading, something we probably could have done ourselves. The best part was when Rafael reviewed several of the different drills to help slicers, which affects 90% of all golfers out there. He also showed us the more than 20 benefits of the feet together drill, and we talked about different training aids. I love using training aids in my teaching. I’ve collected them over the years through my own learning and play, and I now I get to employ them when working with my students. That’s golfing life coming full circle. Even though there are no questions about technology on the Level 2 Test, we got to make a late afternoon visit to the hitting simulators next door and to the brand new Putting Lab that’s adjacent to the Club Lab. The PGA just recently purchased Quintic Ball Roll program to help measure and analyze a player’s putting stroke. The big takeaway from our brief session in the Lab was that we all need to do more putter fittings. There’s a real market out there that’s being underserved. When asked how many of us had been fitted for our putters, only three of us raised their hands. And that’s knowing that almost half of the shots in every round of golf are putts. It doesn’t make sense not to get fitted. Before we left, Rafael asked us the question, “How do you keep your lesson books full?” That’s an interesting question. What we came away with was that you want your students to have fun and get better. And then you want to find a way to market those results. Even with all the social media out there in 2017, word-of-mouth is still the best advertising technique you can use. High energy and enthusiasm is also a plus, and if you’re likeable, there’s a great chance that you’re going to keep your lesson book full. As we learned yesterday, golf instruction is about teaching people more than it is about teaching golf. To close the day, we re-visited the Fitness and Performance

PGA Level 2 Seminar: Day 5 Read More »

PGA Level 2 Seminar: Day 4

Day 4 is the day most of us (including me) have been waiting for. Most if not all of us here at the Level 2 Seminars this week teach lessons, and obviously, there’s a lot we still have to learn. That goes without saying. The presenters for the next two days will be Rafael Floriani (PGA), a PGA Education staff member for the last four years who was here during Level 1, and Brad Brewer (PGA). Brad is the co-owner of a golf academy at Rosen Shingle Creek in Orlando near where they host the PGA Merchandise Show every year. He played in the Austral-Asian Tour for three years and ran the Arnold Palmer Golf Academies at Bay Hill for ten years from 1990-2000. Brad learned a lot from the master himself. Level 2 covers teaching intermediate-level golfers and groups. For many of us, these are our bread-and-butter golfers at our clubs or facilities, the weekend 85 or 90 shooter up to 100. This is the typical person who takes golf lessons from us. Looking ahead, Level 3 is reserved for the instruction of advanced golfers, the single-digit or plus handicap player. Because there was rain in the forecast for much of the afternoon, they flip-flopped today’s schedule. From 8:45a to 10:10a, Brad took us through a group lesson scenario and demonstrated how he would give a driver lesson to a small group of about four people. We were at the back of the practice range at the PGA Center for Golf Learning adjacent to the Education Center. It was fun to watch Brad interact with the group while taking the time to give more specific instruction to each person individually as he went down the line. By the time he was done, he had the group hitting draws and fades. Then Rafael took a turn with another group of four and went through a few different drills designed to get the students to feel the release of the club head, swing more from the inside, and to make better ball/turf contact. It started to sprinkle, but in true Florida fashion, it was short-lived, and we didn’t get rained out. At 10:15, Rafael split the whole group in half, and we shuttled back over to the PGA Education Center. For the next 55 minutes, we gathered in the Club Lab where we reviewed golf club performance numbers and measured and installed grips. We also got to use a grip-ripper, which is usually reserved for more high-volume shops. You just slide the club in the device and pull. Easy as that! We also learned what happens to the grip when you add layers of build-up tape. These are things I had already learned at the Golf Academy, but it was great to get a little refresher. It was also hands-on, which was awesome. Let’s just say that some people are better at installing grips than others. From 11:15a to a little after noon, we headed back out to the back of the practice range with Brad and partnered up for individual lessons. My partner and I took turns giving each other a golf lesson and talking shop. It was great to hear what he was doing with the students he works with back home, and I shared some teaching stories of my own. I tried to throw my partner off by weakening my left hand grip, but he couldn’t be fooled! When we finished, we walked down the line to hear what our peers were saying to each other and how they were teaching. Personally, I’m really glad we changed the schedule. This was our most interactive morning yet, and these are definitely the kinds of group activities I can get behind! Brad later admitted to us that he was glad we reversed the schedule and got to be outside first because it would give us a little perspective for the slides we would be viewing in the afternoon session. “The slides are necessary to make it relevant,” said Brad, “But slides aren’t the best way to learn. Practical application is the best way to learn.” But I have to say that I found the slides to be very helpful. Not coincidentally, the two topics that led off Intermediate Teaching in the afternoon were communication and relationships. In our first exercise, Rafael told us to take five post-it notes, to recall the best teacher we’ve ever had, and then to write down the best five things about that person. When he asked us to separate the pile into “people skills” and “technical stuff” and then put them up, I would say 90% of the post-its went to the people skills side of the room. This wasn’t all that surprising, I guess. After all, we’re teaching people, not golf. That’s also why enthusiasm is so important. Enthusiasm is contagious. If you’re an enthusiastic teacher, that rubs off on your students. Research links student learning to the teacher’s level of enthusiasm. Students of enthusiastic teachers experience greater enjoyment, higher motivation, and more success in their lessons. At the end of the day, all we really want is to feel better about ourselves. That’s just human nature. Incidentally, the teacher I chose was Mike Barnett, and he teaches out of Bear Creek Golf Club in Chandler during the winter months. Preview of Day 4: Intermediate Teaching and Golf Club Alteration (8:30a-6:00p) Once again, we have come to the end of another Seminar week. But man this week has flown by! We’ll pick back up where we left off tomorrow morning. Tomorrow could be an inside day. There are thunderstorms in the forecast from 7:00a until 3:00p, and the percentage chances are high. This also happens to be the longest day on the schedule, and it’s not even close. We didn’t get out of class tonight until almost 5:45p, so hopefully they’ll have a little mercy on us on our last day.

PGA Level 2 Seminar: Day 4 Read More »

PGA Level 2 Seminar: Day 3

I can already tell you, after just a few days back here in Florida, that the Level 2 Seminars have a completely different feel than the Level 1 Seminars. Maybe it’s knowing what to expect or not being as stressed out about the Work Experience Portfolio, but I have to say that it’s actually been a pleasure to be here! The evenings are much more laid back, and there are already way more opportunities to either go play golf at the end of the day or go out and relax with your classmates. It’s a subtle reminder of what a big deal it is to make it through Level 1 and how we all have an obligation to help others at our facilities get through the process, especially Level 1, which is largely designed to weed-out the less motivated. Day 3 was all about Merchandising and Inventory Management. It was a rainy walk from the hotel to the PGA Education Center up the street. There has been rain in the forecast every day this week, and luckily it held off until today. Mark Black (PGA) from Encanterra was back at the helm along with Michelle Hupfer (PGA) who we also had for Level 1. Of course, you can’t do Merchandising without doing a little math. That brings us to the Cost of Goods Sold (COGS) formula. Cost of Goods Sold is often shown as a percentage of sales (COGS/Total Sales = COGS %). It’s usually higher for hard goods than it is for soft goods because hard goods are more expensive. Based on a 2010 PGA Study, sample COGS percentage benchmarks were 50-60% for soft goods, 65-75% for hard goods, and 72% on average, for both categories. After lunch, we continued by developing a fictional Open-to-Buy (OTB) plan and a Merchandise Assortment Plan (MAP) for men’s shirts in one of our Case Studies, Saguaro Sands. An OTB plan tells you how much product you must bring in each month, in each category, to support forecasted sales. Basically, as the rounds ramp up during the year, you want to have the inventory on-hand to handle the rush. A MAP establishes the desired merchandise mix of brands, sizes, colors, materials, models and price points for both soft and hard goods. We also discussed markup approaches from Keystone Pricing to The Mill River Plan and establishing vendor relationships that contribute to the overall growth and success of the merchandise operation. Mark is always talking about the golf boom in the 80s and how everything in the golf industry was so great back then. I asked him how that compared to boom of the late 90s and early 2000s that we’re all more familiar with. He told us that golf in the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s, and 2000s up through Tiger Woods was great up until the lull around 2008. Then he asked us if we noticed that the younger guys on Tour these days all seemed to talk to one another. “Did you notice who had already changed clothes and was there to meet Justin Thomas near the 18th green right after he won the PGA?” Mark asked. We said we saw Jordan Spieth and Rickie Fowler. And that was his point. “The younger guys talk to each other during competition,” he said. “It’s a different animal. They’re actually friends! In my day, if you knew something, you certainly didn’t share it. Think Tiger and Phil (Mickelson). Those guys never talked to each other. I think golf is going to have another boom.” I hope Mark is right. The Beach! A few of my classmates decided to go to the beach when we got out of class around 4:30p, and I was invited to tag along. We jumped into an Uber, and 25 minutes later, we spilled out onto the Fort Pierce Inlet. We took some great shots of the beach on a sunny afternoon, and I have to say, the Atlantic Ocean was a lot warmer than I was expecting it to be. It was a lot warmer than the Pacific, that’s for sure! We saw plenty of pelicans and what we think was a sea lion (or maybe it was a seal). We also saw some fresh coconuts and smashed a couple of them open. Two of my classmates ate some fresh coconut from one while the other drank the water right out of another! Blogger’s Note: My Level 2 Work Experience Portfolio Completion Status is now over 30% complete. I’ve gone about as far as I can go without fudging interviews and making-up answers. I have a few interviews to conduct when I get back to Arizona, most notably with our Director of Agronomy, Head Golf Professional, and Merchandise Manager. I feel pretty good about my progress through just three days. Preview of Day 4: Intermediate Teaching and Golf Club Alteration (8:30a-5:20p) Finally, the moment I’ve been waiting for: Intermediate Teaching and Golf Club Alteration with Rafael Floriani (PGA) and Brad Brewer (PGA). The only problem is that there’s rain in the forecast much of the day. I’m told we may have to flip-flop the schedule so we can go outside in the morning instead of in the afternoon. I hope we’re not cooped up all day! It’s going to be the 2nd-longest day of the week schedule-wise. On Monday, we got out before 5:00p even though we were scheduled to go until 5:30p.

PGA Level 2 Seminar: Day 3 Read More »

PGA Level 2 Seminar: Day 2

Day 2 got off to a booming start with a 25-minute, high-energy breakout session on cover letters, resumes, and interviews with Bill Cioffoletti (PGA) and Michelle Hupfer (PGA) in an nearby classroom. Attendance was optional and not part of the day’s Seminar, but boy was it worth it. Leave it to Bill to make resumes sound exciting! We discussed the importance of networking and how golf professionals as a whole are probably weakest at marketing and selling themselves. It’s not easy, and it’s not always comfortable. But it can make the difference between getting a job and going back to JobFinder at pga.org. Then it was back to Golf Operations and specifically, a discussion on pace-of-play. Numerous factors affect pace-of-play: course design, course set-up and maintenance, and even player behavior. The general consensus was that a pace-of-play program must be promoted to players as well as staff. Better communication from on-course signage to set-up, educating the customer on their role in maintaining proper pace-of-play, and training staff members on how to handle on-course situations all go a long way toward keeping things moving out on the golf course. It’s a very complex issue, and there’s no one right answer on how to handle it. Everyone should be allowed to experience a quality pace-of-play on the golf course. In the afternoon, the conversation shifted to Metrics for Monitoring Performance and Yield Management. I told you Golf Operations was anything but sexy. However, it’s really important because it’s the nuts and bolts that make the golf course churn. Encanterra’s Mark Black (PGA) told us that when we’re analyzing metrics, we have to decide how often we’re going to monitor and what corrective action we’re going to take if there’s a discrepancy. Useful metrics include forecasts, per-round income, cost of goods sold, and gross margin. Yield Management allows a facility to actively monitor and target time slots and price points and can be a particularly useful performance metric. On a lighter note, one of my classmates remarked that Mark sounded a little bit like John Madden. I kept picturing Mark saying things like “Brett Favre” and “Boom!” We were out of class by 3:40p, five minutes earlier than promised even on our shortest-scheduled day! We covered 110 pages of the Golf Operations Seminar Manual in a little less than two days. What would John Madden say about that? It was a lot of wordy slides and not a whole lot of pictures or graphics. Boom! PGA Short Course After class today, I hustled back to the hotel in hopes of catching a ride with some of the guys over to PGA Golf Club to play a little golf. Since we got out so early, I figured the least I could do was to try out the Short Course. But by the time I got back to the hotel, the place had already cleared out. Literally less than ten minutes after class dismissed, and it was already a ghost town! So I decided to head out front to hail an Uber. That’s when one of my classmates came out, told me he was playing, and started walking. Turns out it’s less than a mile away and about a ten minute walk. Incidentally, an Uber X ride will cost you $6.55. After buying a sleeve of balls, I grabbed a complimentary TaylorMade wedge and putter and headed over to the Bunny Slope. What a great idea! I played two balls, and in less than 15 minutes, I was finished playing the six-hole loop because there was hardly anyone else out there. At one point, a full rainbow appeared in the distance. It was so much fun, I decided to play it another couple of times. Each tee box was a mat so as not to tear up the turf, and the greens and surrounding bunkers were in really good shape. The first two holes were 52 and 50 yards long respectively. Those were the only two yardages I saw. If you want to wander away from the hotel and you still want to get in a little golf, the short course is definitely the way to go. And what’s more, it’s free! Now I’m really wishing I’d brought my own sticks. Blogger’s Note: I’m coming to realize that there’s not much you can do with your Level 2 Work Experience Portfolio while you’re at the Seminar. In a lot of ways, that really takes the pressure off during and at the end of each day and is a lot less stressful. It seems like all I did at the end of each seminar day at Level 1 was to knock out as much of the Portfolio as I could before I went home. Level 2 involves a lot more interviews and facility activities that you can’t actually complete until you’re back at your own facility. If you’re being honest, you can only get so far. Without too much effort through two days, my Portfolio is already more than 20% complete. Preview of Day 3: Review of Portfolio/Testing Procedures, Merchandising (8:30a-4:45p) After tomorrow, we’ll be more than halfway home. We’ll get to tackle a new topic too: Merchandising and Inventory Management, which is great. I don’t know much about either subject, so it should be interesting. I really can’t wait for the last two days of the Seminars. That’s Intermediate Teaching and Golf Club Alteration with Rafael Floriani (PGA) and Brad Brewer (PGA). I can’t wait to learn some new tricks and techniques I can take back to my students in Arizona.

PGA Level 2 Seminar: Day 2 Read More »