Hiland Park Country Club

When I asked our host which course he wanted to play this time around, of course he suggested Saratoga National again. But when we couldn’t get on there, he suggested another one of his favorites, Hiland Park Country Club just up the road in Queensbury. The only problem was, when I went to look up the course, the only Highland Park that came up was in Highland Park, Illinois. That’s when I realized Highland was spelled without a “gh.” Hiland Park Country Club is in a beautiful spot tucked at the base of the Southern Adirondack Mountain Region of Lake George, and according to their web site, “is widely considered one of the finest public facilities in the Northeast region of New York State.” Who can argue with that? They have a great looking logo too. It has a tree, some hills, and a road running through it, but it’s the kind of simple, classic logo that will look as good 50 years from now as it does today. The course is also located about 30 minutes outside of Saratoga and the Saratoga Race Course. It’s horse racing season, and while there has typically been only one “dark” or non-race day at America’s oldest racetrack in years past, this year there are two. Now that there’s no racing on Monday or Tuesday, courses like Hiland are jammed. Unlike Arizona, it’s high season baby, and courses like this will see upwards of 200 rounds per day from 6:30 in the morning all the way until sundown at almost eight o’clock. Hiland Park was designed by Stephen Kay, and since opening for play in 1989 has hosted several PGA Qualifying events as well as the New York State Open. I had never played a Kay design before, so I was really excited about playing this parkland-style layout. The course plays 6,797 yards from the Blue Tees to a Par of 72, a course rating of 72.8, and a slope of 137. Here are some of the highlights of the round: Holes Worth Writing Home AboutI thought the best hole on the front nine was the downhill Par 3 6th. And boy are we talking downhill! This is where you’re going to want to have your phone ready to snap a picture because it’s going to be your best view of the day. Because the course isn’t overly long, one of its best defenses is the relatively small size of its bentgrass greens. Hole 6 is a perfect example. The hole measured 148 yards, but I played the shot as if it was closer to 130 because of the elevation change. There’s really no good place to miss. There are bunkers short right, short left, and long left, and if you hit your ball long right, there’s a good chance it will land on the downslope and bounce into the surrounding wetlands area. My tee shot was in the air for what felt like forever, but when it finally came down on the green, I was happy to take my two putts and get out of there with a par. On the back nine, holes 15-18 make for a really nice finishing stretch. Hole 15 is a long Par 3 over water, 16 is a driveable, risk/reward dogleg Par 4 over water, Hole 17 is a 461-yard Par 4, and 18 is a reachable Par 5. You can pick up a couple of strokes here if you play your cards right. These holes are all good, but the 351-yard Par 4 16th is the real gem if you ask me. I’ve always said that if I designed a golf course, I would have a driveable Par 4 late in the back nine simply to add a little drama. I think 3-wood is the play off this tee. Aim for the bunker on the far left, and curl a little draw around the dogleg to avoid the water and giant willow tree waiting to swat any shot that’s not high enough, right enough, or left enough (if you’re going for the green) into the water. Hit driver and you not only risk going through the fairway onto No. 11, you’re also asking for tree trouble. If you do go for the green and come up short, you’re wet. But there is a small opening between the bunkers short left and short right, so if you’re brimming with confidence, it’ll definitely make for an entertaining tee shot. The difference between the blue and the white tees at Hiland Park is a little less than 400 yards, but the tees were in almost identical locations with few exceptions. It was hard to see where they got the extra yardage on the scorecard, but if I had to guess, I would say a majority of it comes between tees on the front nine. Unlike the courses we have in the desert, there are no sand bottles on the carts or out on the course. Because these are bentgrass fairways, when you take a divot, you simply replace that beaver pelt and tap it down with your foot. I’m not used to doing that. Quiet Please…A really cool thing happened when I went into the Tudor-style Golf Shop to check-in. Assistant Golf Professional Brian Jeffers said, “I have a really strange question for you. Are you the guy who posts PGA Study Guides on his web site?” When I told him I was, he exclaimed, “Your Study Guide helped me pass Level 2!” That exchange really made my day and is exactly what I had in mind when I started my web site and began documenting my PGA Membership journey in the first place. I wanted fellow Associates to be able to learn from my successes and failures and to be able to pass their tests. I figured if I was going to do the work anyway, I might as well post it for others to take advantage of and use. It reminded me of my experience at the PGA Level 3

Hiland Park Country Club Read More »

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Bunker Incidents & More

I first met Dr. Robin Farran back when I was a student at the Golf Academy of America. Not only is he one of the USGA’s top Rules Officials, Dr. Farran is a one-man wrecking crew when it comes to educating others about the nuances of the Rules. He once told me that his weekly email list was more than 400 strong, and I’m proud to say I’m one of those recipients. In this month’s Diary of a USGA Rules Official, Dr. Farran first takes us into the bunker to school us on the Rules in and around the sand: Bunker IncidentsIncident 1Player A’s ball is in a bunker. Player A’s next stroke is OB. Prior to dropping a ball in the relief area as defined by Rule 14.6b, Player A rakes the bunker, restoring the bunker to the condition prior to the stroke. **Rule 12.2b(3) states that there are no restrictions on touching or smoothing sand in a bunker after the ball is played out of the bunker. Incident 2 Player A’s ball is in a bunker. After lifting the ball and prior to proceeding under Rule 19.3b, Player A rakes the bunker, restoring the bunker to the condition prior to taking relief. **In proceeding under Rule 19.3b, Player A will be proceeding under back-on-the line relief outside the bunker. Although Rule 8.1a and Interpretation 8.1a/1 state that the penalty for improving the conditions affecting the stroke by raking a bunker on the line of play is the general penalty, Interpretation 12.2b(3)/1 clarifies that Player A is allowed to smooth sand in the bunker to care for the course when intending to take relief outside the bunker. Interpretation 12.2b(3)/1 states, “The term “played out of the bunker” in Rule 12.2b(3) also includes taking relief outside the bunker”. Incident 3 Player A’s ball is embedded in the dirt face of a deep bunker. Player A elects to proceed under the back-on-the-line relief option for a ball unplayable and drops the ball in the general area. **Player A’s ball lies in the general area – see Definition of Bunker. In proceeding under Rule 19.2b, Player A may drop the ball in any area of the course incurring a penalty of one stroke. Incident 4Player A’s ball is in the fairway about 120 yards from the hole behind a low-faced bunker. A player in a previous group did not rake the bunker. While waiting for his or her turn to play, Player A restores the bunker to its original condition. **Most likely, Player A did not create a potential advantage for his or her next stroke so raking the bunker for care of the course is permitted. See Rules 8.1 and 8.1a and Interpretation 8.1a/2. Incident 5 Player A’s ball is in the light rough near the putting green just behind a high-faced bunker close to the putting green. Prior to playing his or her next stroke, Player A rakes the footprints in the bunker, restoring the bunker to its original condition. **Player A incurs the general penalty for improving conditions affecting the stroke, a breach of Rule 8.1a – see Rule 8.1 and Interpretation 8.1a/1. Incident 5Player A’s ball is in a bunker on the sand resting against a soda can. As Player A removes the soda can, the ball moves several inches. Player A lifts the ball and replaces the ball carefully on the original spot. **Player A has proceeded correctly – see Rule 15.1(1). Incident 6Player A’s ball is in a bunker on the sand resting against a pinecone. As Player A removes the pinecone, the ball moves several inches. Player A lifts the ball and replaces the ball carefully on the original spot. **Player A gets a penalty of one stroke for moving a ball in play – see Rule 15.1b. Incident 7Player A’s ball comes to rest on a towel in a bunker. Player A lifts the ball, removes the towel and places the ball on the spot directly under where the ball originally lay on the towel. **Player A gets the general penalty for placing a ball when the relief procedure requires dropping a ball – see Rule 15.2a(2). Also, see Rule 14.3b(3), last bullet. Incident 8While Player A is waiting to play the ball from a fairway bunker, Player A leans on his or her club touching the sand. Player A sees a stone partly buried several inches in front of the ball and removes the stone prior to making the stroke. **Loose impediments may be removed from bunkers – see Rule 15-1a. There is no penalty for leaning on a club touching sand in a bunker – see Rule 12-2b(2). Incident 9Player A’s ball comes to rest in a deep footprint in a bunker. As Player A enters the bunker, in frustration, Player A strikes the sand with his or her wedge. During the backswing for the stroke from the bunker, Player A’s club touches the sand in the bunker. **There is no penalty for striking the sand with a club in frustration or anger – see Rule 12.2b(2). Player A gets the general penalty for the club touching sand in the bunker during the backswing for the stroke – see Rule 12.2b(1). Incident 10Player A’s ball played from the teeing area strikes a large palm tree near a spectator that is following Player A’s round. When Player A and his or her group arrive in the area, there is no ball visible in the tree. The spectator informs the players that he is “virtually certain” that Player A’s ball is in the palm tree. **Player A’s ball is lost if not found and identified within three minutes after Player A begins to search for his or her ball – see Rule 18.2(1). In order to be found, the ball must be visible and identified as Player A’s ball – see Rule 7.2 and Interpretation 7.2/1. Player A must return to the teeing area and play another ball under penalty of stroke and distance – see Rule 18.2b. Incident 11An

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Bunker Incidents & More Read More »

The Golf Club at Mansion Ridge

When my brother, who graduated from West Point back in 2009, told my wife and I that he would be returning to his alma mater for a two-year teaching stint beginning this fall, we started looking for ways to visit before the summer was over. For the past several years, my brother and his family have lived up and down the east coast, but between us starting a family and me pursuing my PGA Class A Certification, we just couldn’t find a way to make a trip work… until now. One of the courses my brother has had his eye on playing since relocating is The Golf Club at Mansion Ridge in Monroe, New York. It’s a little more than 30 minutes away from West Point and just happens not only to be a Troon Golf property but also a Jack Nicklaus Signature Golf Course like La Paloma Country Club in Tucson where I work. I couldn’t wait to compare Nicklaus designs! The course opened for play in 1999 and is located at the foothills of the Catskill Mountains in the historic highlands of what’s considered the Hudson Valley. It was built around natural tree lines and wetlands on an historic 220 acres with landmarks predating the American Revolution. The natural stone walls that frame the Par 3 5th and the Par 4 10th holes almost make you feel as if you could see muskets and smell gunpowder. The Golf Club at Mansion Ridge plays 6,889 yards from the Tour Tees to a Par of 72, a course rating of 74.9, and a slope of 145. There are five sets of tees on each hole, and all of the tee markers look like headstones you would find in a cemetery and feature the Mansion Ridge “MR” logo. Here are some of the highlights of the round: Holes Worth Writing Home AboutWhen we rolled up to the first tee looking for a little local course knowledge, the starter told us to expect to be lulled to sleep for the first few holes before getting jarred awake at the 9th. He wasn’t wrong. Mansion Ridge was once ranked among the Top 20 Best Public Golf Courses in New York by Golf Digest, and holes like No. 9 are a big reason why. The 9th hole, called Hunting Ground, is by far the most difficult hole on the entire golf course and can best be described as diabolical. The 539-yard Par 5 looks pretty tame from the tee, but between your tee shot and your elevated second, there is a sizable forced carry due to a creek bisecting the fairway. It’s high season in upstate New York. The fairways are green, and the native grasses are tall and lush. No doubt, this was one of the “extreme elevation changes” that accompany the spectacular 50-mile views of graceful ridges and rolling foothills that make up the surrounding countryside described on the Nicklaus Design web site. This is a mountain course to be sure. Should you clear that creek, there’s another one waiting to collect your ball short of the elevated green. Crushed shell bunkers short left and long right look to wreak even more havoc if your approach shot lacks the proper distance. All of the holes at Mansion Ridge have names, which I love, and I have to say that No. 9 is named appropriately. At one point, I didn’t know if we were the hunters or the hunted. The course also features some pretty stunning rock formations throughout, none more evident than the gneiss rock face next to the green after you turn onto the 446-yard Par 4 14th known as Bear Corner. Gneiss (pronounced NICE) is a metamorphic rock common to the area and looks a lot like granite. This grass-covered outcropping on this slight dogleg right has to be at least 30-feet high in some spots and really frames the hole nicely (no pun intended). Quiet Please…Another thing the starter told us was that the greens weren’t all that undulating for a Nicklaus course. He was right about that too! These were by far the least-undulating Nicklaus greens I have ever played, which is surprising. The greens at La Paloma, in true Nicklaus fashion, have a ton of slope and break. Could this be a sign of a new, softer Jack? While the fairways are completely bentgrass, the greens are bentgrass mixed with a little poa. “Unless your course is new,” one of the superintendents driving around the course told us, “you’re going to have a little poa.” Even though maintenance couldn’t mow them because it rained overnight, the greens were still really true. About the only negative thing I can say about Mansion Ridge concerns the driving range located next to the 18th-century stone clubhouse. Because the carts were on GPS lockdown, you couldn’t drive them down the steep hill to the practice area, but why bother? The day we were there, you could only hit irons off of mats, and even if the turf tees were open, there’s no way it’s long enough for you to hit your driver. The best warm-up you’re going to get will be off the grass over at the short game area where at least you can hit pitch shots and some approach wedges for a little turf interaction. It’s too bad there’s not more room for players to hit longer clubs before they play or even if they wanted to come out and practice. There were several screeching hawks flying overhead and a ton of Monarch butterflies fluttering about when we played. Apparently, they were still a couple of weeks early. In late August, masses of Monarchs begin an epic migration stretching thousands of miles from areas across the United States and as far north as Canada (east of the Rocky Mountains) to overwinter in the mountaintops of Central Mexico. Fore!So there we no real candidates for a “shot of the day,” but since our threesome skipped the 3rd hole to get around a slow foursome, my

The Golf Club at Mansion Ridge Read More »