Blog

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Ruling References

Dr. Robin Farran teaches Advanced Rules at the Golf Academy of America in Phoenix and is one of the United States Golf Association’s (USGA) top Rules Officials. He’s always emailing out different Rules scenarios, and I like to post them all about one a month as a little refresher. In this month’s Diary of a USGA Rules Official, Dr. Farran plays one of my favorite game shows, Okay or Not Okay? Okay or Not Okay? 1. Player A’s ball is on a paved cart path. Player A marks and lifts the ball and then realizes that the nearest point of relief is in a large bush. Player A replaces the ball on the cart path and completes the hole. **Player A incurred a penalty of one stroke for a breach of Rule 18-2. Player A was permitted to lift the ball without penalty to proceed under Rule 24-2. When Player A did not proceed to take relief from the obstruction, Player A is deemed to have moved the ball in play without permission of a Rule; Rule 18-2 now applies. [See Decision 18-2/12.] 2. Player B’s ball is on a paved cart path. Player B marks and lifts the ball and drops the ball from waist height within one club-length of the nearest point of relief, not nearer the hole. When reminded by another player about the proper method of dropping the ball, Player B lifts the ball, reconsiders taking relief from the cart path, replaces the ball on the cart path and completes the hole. **Player B incurred the general penalty for a breach of Rule 24-2. Rule 20-6 permitted Player B to lift the ball that was dropped incorrectly and correct the dropping procedure. Player B must proceed in accordance with Rule 24 to avoid any penalties. [See Rule 20-6 and Decision 20-6/5.] 3. Player C’s ball is on a paved cart path. Player C marks and lifts the ball and drops the ball about two club-lengths from the edge of the cart path. When reminded by another player of the correct procedure for taking relief from the cart path, Player C reconsiders taking relief from the cart path, replaces the ball on the cart path and completes the hole. **Player C incurred the general penalty for a breach of Rule 24-2. When Player C dropped the ball with the intent to take relief without penalty from the cart path, Player C was committed to proceed correctly to avoid any penalties. [See Rule 20-6 and Decision 20-6/5.] Ruling References? In the following incidents, determine any relevant Definitions, Rules and Decisions that are required for the appropriate ruling. 1. Player A’s ball lands in a hazard close to a plastic water bottle. The water bottle interferes with Player A’s stance. **Definition of “Movable Obstruction” and Rule 24-1. A movable obstruction may be removed anywhere on the course (or off the course). Also, if the movement of the movable obstruction causes the ball to move, there is no penalty and the ball must be replaced. 2. Player B’s approach shot flies over the putting green towards several spectators. One of the spectators jumped in front of the ball to stop the ball from going into a wooded area behind the green. After being deflected by the spectator, the ball came to rest just beyond the green. **Definition of “Outside Agency” and Note to Rule 19-1, item (a). Decision 19-1/4.1 provides guidance. The player must drop the ball as near as possible to the spot where it is estimated that the ball would have come to rest. 3. Player C and Player D both hit their balls into a lateral water hazard. The players do not know which ball is farther from the hole but it is known that Player D’s ball crossed the hazard margin farther from the hole than where Player C’s ball crossed the hazard margin. **Rule 10-1b and Rule 10-2b and Decision 10/3. Order of play “should be decided by lot” since the locations of the balls are not known. Hole No. 9 – The Ruling The cart path on hole #9 runs parallel to the fairway and is about 2 feet from the boundary wall. There is no vegetation, bushes or trees along the cart path. The tee shot of Player A, a capable junior golfer, came to rest about 1 foot from the wall on the dirt. Player A, a right-handed player, determined that he could play the ball left-handed and would be entitled to relief from the cart path. Player A, with his 9-iron, determined his nearest point of relief for a right-handed stroke on the fairway side of the card path, measured the one club-length area carefully with his driver and dropped a ball in the grass about 10 inches farther from the cart path and not nearer the hole than the nearest point of relief for the right-handed shot and continued play of the hole. At scoring, one of the fellow-competitors questioned the scoring official about Player A’s procedure. **We know that Player A did not follow the correct procedure in taking relief from the cart path for a left-handed stroke. However, the Rules only require the player to drop the ball where the Rule prescribes and play from a correct place. We need to determine whether Player A played from a wrong place, a breach of Rule 24-2 or whether Player A played from a location that met the requirements of Rule 24-2. In reviewing the facts on the course, including the divot where the dropped ball was played, Player A proceeded in accordance with Rule 24-2. Player Penalties! How many total penalty strokes in each incident? 1. Player A’s ball is in an area marked as a lateral water hazard. Player A informs his fellow-competitors that he intends to take relief from the lateral water hazard, knows the reference point for Rule 26-1c, and will look for his ball in the hazard. Player A, while searching in the hazard, tosses

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Ruling References Read More »

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Just the Facts Ma’am

It’s been a busy month for the Rules of Golf, and I would be surprised if Dr. Robin Farran didn’t have a little something to do with it. Dr. Farran teaches Advanced Rules at the Golf Academy of America in Phoenix and is one of the United States Golf Association’s (USGA) top Rules Officials. Late last month, the USGA and the R&A came together to announce changes limiting the use of video evidence in making rulings at televised events… effective immediately. Now that’s something you don’t see from those organizations every day! Usually, they’re much more slow moving (as in 1-3 years minimum to make a change of this magnitude). In this month’s Diary of a USGA Rules Official, Dr. Farran has several scenarios up for our consideration: Real-Life Incidents – April 25, 2017 – Considerations and Rulings The point of these incidents is to address the process of reaching a correct ruling. To make a correct ruling we need to know: Where was the ball? Was the ball in play? 1. Player A, who finished his round, asked the scoring official the following question; “My ball was very close to a sprinkler head. I was sure that my club would have hit the sprinkler head during the stroke so I took relief. Is that OK?” **For a ball in play and lies through the green, in a bunker or on a putting green, the player is entitled to relief without penalty from an immovable obstruction unless the Exception to Rule 24-2 applies.  From questioning, it was learned that Player A’s ball was in a lateral water hazard. Rule 24-2 does not apply.  When Player A lifted, dropped and played the ball, Player A is deemed to have proceeded under Rule 26-1 and incurred a penalty of one stroke under Rule 26-1 and an additional two-stroke penalty under Rule 26-1 for playing from a wrong place – the dropped ball did not meet the requirements of any of the Rule 26-1 options. [See Note 1 in Rule 26-1 and Decision 20-7/2.] 2. Player B approaches an official with a question. Player B describes that he was making a practice swing near his ball and accidentally struck the ball. **A player is in breach of Rule 18-2 when a ball in play is moved by a practice swing except when the ball in play is on the putting green and the Local Rule for 2017 is in effect.  It turns out that Player B’s ball was on a tee in the teeing ground and was not in play. No penalty was incurred and Player B could replace the ball on the tee or start the hole as he wishes. 3. A bug is crawling near Player C’s ball. Player C waves his hand at the bug and moves his ball. **The bug is a loose impediment. For a ball that is in play and through the green or in a hazard, a player is penalized for moving his or her ball in play and the ball must be replaced. (Player touching a bug on a ball in a hazard is a breach of Rule 13-4c – see Decision 23-1/5.) Player C’s ball was on the putting green, therefore as noted in Rule 23-1, there is no penalty for moving a ball in play on the putting green when the movement of the ball is directly attributable to the act of removing a loose impediment. The ball must be replaced. Real-Life Incident – April 18, 2017 – The Rulings In each of the following incidents, what was Player A’s score for the hole? Player A’s ball from his tee shot lies within a water hazard in a difficult lie. Player A’s shot played from within the water hazard heads toward the OB. Player A announces intent to play a provisional ball which, when dropped, rolls into an unplayable location (no re-drop required). Player A lifts the ball and drops it outside the water hazard, proceeding under Rule 26-1b. Player A’s next stroke after the drop lands short of the putting green. 1. Player A’s original ball is found on the course. Player A picks up the provisional ball and completes the hole with the original ball in three additional strokes. **Player A scored 5 for the hole. The original ball was found. (Tee shot = 1s, Stroke in WH = 1s, Strokes with original ball = 3s; Score for hole = 5) 2. Player A finds his original ball out of bounds. Player A completes the hole with the provisional ball in three additional strokes. **Player A scored 8 for the hole. Since the original ball was not found, the strokes taken with the provisional ball dropped in the water hazard count in the score including the stroke and distance penalty and penalty for relief from the water hazard. (Tee shot = 1s, Stroke in WH = 1s, Provisional ball dropped = 1p, Relief from WH  = 1p, Stroke to putting green = 1s, Additional strokes = 3s; Score for hole = 8) Review Items – April 10, 2017 – The Answers 1. In stroke play, a player announces that he will play two balls under Rule 3-3 and selects the second ball to count. The player plays the original ball in accordance with the Rules and the second ball from a wrong place. What is the ruling? a) The score with the original ball counts. b) The score with the second ball counts. **See Rule 3-3. Rule 3-3b(1) provides guidance for the Committee determination. 2. Which of the following is TRUE with regard to the nearest point of relief for taking relief under Rule 24-2 or Rule 25-1. a) This point must be determined prior to the drop; the player may use any club in his bag. b) It is a point where if the ball were so positioned, no interference (as defined) would exist. c) While determining this point, the location of the ball’s original position must be marked. d) The ball’s original location must

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Just the Facts Ma’am Read More »

To Younger Me From Older Me

Dear Younger Me, I can’t play golf anymore. I tried to swing the club the other day, but my body wouldn’t cooperate. The best I can do now is to sometimes take walks out on the course, but my eyes aren’t as good as they used to be, so I don’t see much. I have a lot of time to sit and think now, and I often think about the game. Golf was my favorite game. I played it most of my adult life. I played thousands of rounds and spent thousands of hours practicing. As I look back, I guess I had a pretty good time. But now that I can’t do it anymore, I wish I had done things a little differently. It’s funny, but with all the time I spent playing golf, I never thought that I was a real golfer. I never felt that I was good enough to really belong out there. It doesn’t make much sense since I scored better than average and a lot of people envied my game, but I always felt that if I was just a little better or a little more consistent that I’d really feel good. I’d be satisfied with my game. But I never was. It was always, “One of these days, I’ll get it,” or “One day, I’ll get there.” And now, here I am. I can’t play anymore, and I never got there. I met a lot of different people out on the course. That was one of the best things about the game. But aside from my regular partners and a few others, I don’t feel like I really got to know many of those people very well. I know they didn’t really get to know me. At times, they probably didn’t want to. I was pretty occupied with my own game most of the time and didn’t have much time for anyone else, especially if I wasn’t playing well. So why am I writing you this letter anyway? Just to complain? Not really. Like I said, my golfing experience wasn’t that bad. But it could have been so much better, and I see that so clearly now. I want to tell you so you can learn from it. I don’t want you getting to my age and feeling the same regrets I’m feeling now. I wish, I wish. Sad words I suppose, but necessary. I wish I could have played the game with more joy, more freedom. I was always so concerned with “doing it right” that I never seemed to be able to just enjoy doing it at all. I was so hard on myself, never satisfied, always expecting more. Who was I trying to please? Certainly not myself, because I never did. If there were people whose opinions were important enough to justify all that self-criticism, I never met them. I wish I could have been a better playing partner. I wasn’t a bad person to be with really, but I wish I had been friendlier and gotten to know people better. I wish I could have laughed and joked more and given people more encouragement. I probably would have gotten more from them, and I would have loved that. There were a few bad apples over the years, but most of the people I played with were friendly, polite, and sincere. They really just wanted to make friends and have a good time. I wish I could have made more friends and had a better time. I’m inside a lot now, and I miss the beauty of the outdoors. For years, when I was golfing, I walked through some of the most beautiful places on earth, and yet, I don’t feel as if I really saw them. Beautiful landscapes, trees, flowers, animals, the sky, the ocean. How could I have missed so much? What else was I thinking of that was so important? My grip? My backswing? My stance? Sure, I needed to think about those things sometimes, but so often as to be oblivious to so much beauty? And what about all the green! The wonderful, deep, lush color of green. My eyes are starting to fail me now. I wish I had used them better then so I would have more vivid memories. So what is it that I’m trying to say? I played the type of game that I thought I should play to please the type of people who I thought I should please. But it didn’t work. My game was mine to play, but I gave it away. It’s a wonderful game. Please don’t lose yours. Play a game that you want to play. Play a game that gives you joy and satisfaction and makes you a better person to your family and friends. Play with enthusiasm. Play with freedom. Appreciate the beauty of nature and the people around you. Realize how lucky you are to be able to do it. All too soon your time will be up, and you won’t be able to play anymore. Play a game that enriches your life. That’s all I have to say. I don’t really know how this letter will get to you, but I hope that it reaches you in time. Take care. Signed, Older Me

To Younger Me From Older Me Read More »

A Good Golf Joke…

During my physical examination, my doctor asked me about my physical activity level. I described a typical day: “Yesterday afternoon, I took a five-hour walk about seven miles along some pretty rough terrain. I waded along the edge of a lake. I pushed my way through brambles.” I continued, “I got sand in my shoes and in my eyes. I almost stepped on a snake. I climbed several rocky hills, and I even took a few ‘leaks’ behind some trees. The mental stress of it all left me so shattered, I drank eight beers when I was finished.” Inspired by the story, the doctor exclaimed, “You must be one hell of an outdoorsman!” “No,” I replied, “I’m just a bad golfer.”

A Good Golf Joke… Read More »

Rules of Golf Limits Use of Video Evidence

The Rules of Golf are changing again, and this time, it really is for the better. The topic involved is video evidence, and specifically the events of the past year that have affected Dustin Johnson, Anna Nordqvist, and most recently, Lexi Thompson. Earlier this month, Thompson received a four-stroke penalty in the middle of the final round of the ANA Inspiration, eventually costing her a major championship. It was pretty embarrassing. Not for Thompson, but for the game of golf. Here’s the best article that I could find about the new rules limiting video evidence, effective immediately: USGA and R&A Announce Immediate Changes Limiting Power of Video Evidence By Jaime Diaz GolfDigest.com Well, that was fast. In an uncommonly swift reaction to the uproar that ensued after Lexi Thompson was penalized four strokes while leading late in the final round of the recent ANA Inspiration, the USGA and R&A have announced the implementation – effective immediately – of a New Decision to the Rules of Golf that will mitigate the power of video evidence while reinforcing the traditional reliance on player integrity in making rulings at televised events. New Decision 34-3/10 is not in itself a rule. Instead, it will implement two interpretative terms that tournament committees can apply to limit the use of video – “reasonable standard of judgment” and “naked eye.” The first relates directly to how Thompson earlier this month incurred a two-stroke penalty when officials reviewed video evidence after an email from a television viewer received on the Sunday of the ANA alleged that she had replaced her ball on a short putt about an inch from its original spot during the third round the day before. Afterward, Thompson said that she had been unaware of missing the original spot and had done so unintentionally. The new decision now states that when a player determines a position in situations that include the nearest point of relief or replacing a lifted ball, he or she should not be held to “the degree of precision that can sometimes be provided by video technology.” According to the key language, “so long as the player does what can reasonably be expected under the circumstances to make an accurate determination, the player’s reasonable judgment will be accepted, even if later shown to be inaccurate by the use of video evidence.” “We are trying to make sure that players that are on television are not held to a higher standard than others playing the game,” said Thomas Pagel, the USGA’s senior director of rules. “Television evidence can reveal facts that as a human being you could not reasonably have known in the playing of the game. A player could do everything he or she could to get it right, but video evidence could still show that they got it a little wrong. And the only reason we can know they got it a little wrong is because we’ve been able to slow down, pause, rewind, replay, all the things that the player on the golf course doesn’t have the advantage of doing.” The “naked eye” standard is a response in large part to Anna Nordqvist being penalized two strokes during her three-hole aggregate playoff with Brittany Lang at last year’s U.S. Women’s Open after high-definition, slow-motion video showed her to have brushed sand during her backswing in a fairway bunker on the second hole of the playoff. Nordqvist said she had been unaware of touching the sand. The new decision states that if a committee concludes that such an act “could not reasonably have been seen with the naked eye and the player was not otherwise aware of the potential breach, the player will be deemed not to have breached the Rules, even when video technology shows otherwise.” A foundational subtext for the new decision was the one-stroke penalty that Dustin Johnson was assessed in the final round of last year’s U.S. Open after video evidence was used to determine that he had caused his ball to move while preparing to stroke a short putt on the fifth green. Johnson contended that his actions had not caused the ball to move. Unlike Thompson and Nordqvist, Johnson went on to win, but the outcry about the ruling led the USGA and R&A to enact within six months a Local Rule that states a ball at rest on the green that is accidentally moved by the player can be replaced without penalty. With today’s announcement, the USGA and the R&A have responded to a specific situation and implemented a change with unprecedented speed. “I can’t speak historically,” Pagel said, “but certainly in my time, it’s the fastest we’ve acted.” Both of the new standards have been extensively discussed as part of the Rules modernization initiative, scheduled to take effect on Jan. 1, 2019, which is intended to make the rules more understandable and concise. The “standard of reasonable judgment”, designed to limit the second-guessing that can result from video evidence, was proposed under the rules modernization initiative on March 1, and will now be adopted. The incentive to act was the result of a general acknowledgement that the use of video evidence was continuing to cause controversial rulings with potentially unjust outcomes that were having a negative impact on the perception and business of the game. “From Day 1 following the incident with Lexi Thompson, the various partners in the game’s administration shared that concern, not just the players or the tours,” Pagel said. “The urgency here was not through anything we might have been hearing through the media per player comments. The urgency here was we knew we had a solution and we wanted to act quickly. It’s the right thing for the game. If we were to stand back and say, We know we have these standards, we know we will have them in 2019, let’s just go ahead and wait, that wouldn’t be the right thing for the game.” When the leaders of golf’s major stakeholders – the USGA, R&A, PGA Tour,

Rules of Golf Limits Use of Video Evidence Read More »