Blog

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: True or False?

Dr. Robin Farran teaches Advanced Rules at the Golf Academy of America in Phoenix and is one of the USGA’s top Rules Officials. You have to wonder what he would say about Lexi Thompson’s delayed four-stroke penalty over the weekend! Dr. Farran is always emailing out different scenarios and actual rulings. In this month’s Diary of a USGA Rules Official, the good doctor plays a little True or False? among other things: Saturday Incidents – March 23, 2017 – The Rulings 1. Player A takes relief from a concrete cart path and places the ball on the turf close to the cart path and plays the ball from that location with his stance on the cart path. **Player A has played from a wrong place in taking relief under Rule 24-2 and has not dropped the ball as prescribed by the Rule. In match play, Player A loses the hole. In stroke play, Player A incurs a two-stroke penalty. See Note 3, item (b) under Rule 20-7. 2. In deep rough, Player B strikes the ball a second time while the club is moving forward. The ball pops up and comes down striking the club. **Player B incurs a one-stroke penalty. Player B breached Rule 14-4 and was liable for 1p for striking a ball twice during the stroke and also breached Rule 19-2 for the ball in motion after a stroke striking Player B’s equipment. However, as Player B breached two Rules as a result of a single act, Player B incurs only a single one-stroke penalty. See Decision 1-4/12, situation 2. 3. Player C uses a small stone to mark the one-club distance from the nearest point of relief in taking relief from an obstruction. The dropped ball lands where prescribed by Rule 24-2, bounces off the stone and comes to rest within the prescribed area. **Player C’s ball is properly in play. No re-drop is required for a dropped ball being deflected by a loose impediment. 4. In four-ball match play, it is side D/E’s turn to play. Both Player D and Player E chip at the same time near the putting green and the balls collide on the putting green. **Both balls are to be played from wherever the balls came to rest, without any penalties. See Rule 19-5b. True or False? 1. Player takes relief for an embedded ball and drops the ball just within one club-length of the nearest point of relief, not nearer the hole. The player has proceeded properly.  True False **See Rule 25-2.  2. A competitor took relief from a lateral water hazard, dropped a ball in a wrong place (not a serious breach) and played the ball. The total penalty is three strokes.  True False **One-stroke penalty under Rule 26-1 for relief and a two-stroke penalty for playing from a wrong place. See Rule 26-1, Rule 20-7c and the penalty statement following Rule 26.  3. When a ball is in motion after a stroke, a flagstick lying on the fringe may be lifted to prevent the ball from striking the flagstick.  True False **See last sentence in Rule 24-1.  4. A player properly plays a provisional ball. If the original ball is found in a terrible lie the player may deem the original ball unplayable and continue play with the provisional ball.  True False **See Rule 27-2c and Decision 27-2c/2.  5. A ball lands on the roof of the clubhouse, an obstruction, exact location unknown. For the purpose of taking relief, the ball is deemed to lie at the spot where the ball last crossed the outermost limits of the obstruction.  True False **See Rule 24-3b(i).  6. Vegetation within an area marked as ground under repair interferes with the backswing for the player’s next stroke. The ball lies through the green outside the GUR. The player is entitled to relief.  True False **See Definition of “Ground Under Repair” and Decision 25-1a/1.  7. Once a ball is declared lost it becomes a wrong ball even if found before the five-minute search period expires.  True False **See Definition of “Lost Ball” and Decision 27/16.  8. In match play, if a player plays from a wrong place in taking relief from a cart path, the player loses the hole.  True False **See Rule 20-7b, Rule 24-2b and penalty statement following Rule 24.  9. At any time, a player may play a ball, under penalty of one stroke, from where the original ball was last played.  True False **See Rule 27-1a.  10. If a ball is found in a water hazard, the player may play the ball as it lies or, under penalty of one stroke, play a ball at the spot where the original ball was last played or drop a ball behind the water hazard on a line with the hole and the point where the ball last crossed the margin of the hazard (on the “flag-line”).  True False **See Rule 26-1a and Rule 26-1b. 11. A player’s ball lies in a water hazard. Prior to deciding whether to play the ball as it lies or take relief the player moves a loose impediment in the hazard. If the player elects to take relief from the hazard there is no penalty for moving the loose impediment.  True False **See Rule 13-4c and Decision 13-4/17. Easy? Maybe! 1.    Which of the following is a wrong ball? a)    A player’s second ball played under Rule 3-3. b)    A ball that has been substituted for the original ball that was lifted on the putting green. c)    A ball that lies out of bounds. **See Definitions of “Ball in Play” and “Wrong Ball”. d)    A player’s provisional ball. 2.    In which of the following instances is a player deemed to have made a stroke? a)    A player’s club strikes a tree limb during his backswing and breaks in half. b)    The player “checks his swing” – swinging over the top of the ball on purpose. c)    In the fairway, a player hits his ball accidentally with a practice swing. d)    A player

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: True or False? Read More »

My Epic Experience

About two months ago, I was asked to become a Callaway Golf staff member, meaning that I would represent the brand at La Paloma Country Club where I work. I had served as a Callaway Advocate since June, and after attending the company’s Epic Tour stop in Scottsdale in December, the decision was a no-brainer. One of the perks of being “on staff” with Callaway is being custom fitted for a set of golf clubs. I’m contractually obligated to play at least 12 Callaway clubs in my bag of 14. While I could have elected to go to the Callaway Performance Center at Troon North Golf Club in Scottsdale for an indoor fitting, my preference was to go straight to the source: Callaway’s corporate headquarters in Carlsbad, California. Surprisingly, four of the world’s largest golf manufacturers are located within just a few miles of one another in Southern California: Callaway, Titleist, TaylorMade, and Cobra-Puma. Andrew Mlynarski, who is our Regional Account Representative at Callaway Golf, is the guy I call every time we need to place an order for the Country Club. He’s great, and he was quick to set me up with a fitting at Callaway’s corporate office. But when I learned that it would be another indoor fitting, I asked if there was any way I could do an outdoor fitting at Callaway’s nearby performance center just a few miles up the road from the corporate offices. I could tell that this was going to be a challenge, but hey, if you’re going to do it, why not do it right? Turns out it was a bigger deal than even I thought. After getting approval from his bosses and narrowing it down to a specific set of dates, we settled on a Friday in late March. At lunch before the fitting, Andrew told me that in his two plus years of being a Regional Account Representative, he’s never had a staffer go through an outdoor fitting at the performance center. The experience is generally reserved for Callaway Master Staffers (of which there are only about 40 nationwide), the occasional VIP, and Tour players. In fact, many of the PGA, LPGA, and Web.com players who play Callaway and live in the area will use the facility as a private place to practice, which is why setting a fitting date was such a big deal. Callaway tells you when they can accommodate you, and if Phil Mickelson or Jim Furyk wants to use it, naturally they get first priority. Andrew told me, “I’m not saying this is a once in a lifetime experience, but it’s pretty close.” Now I was really getting excited. But first we had some time to kill, and Andrew had offered to give me and my wife a behind-the-scenes tour prior to the fitting, an offer we graciously accepted. From the moment we walked through the doors, our treatment was first-class, beginning with Mary the receptionist who gave my wife a Callaway hat and visor. Then Andrew took us back into all the offices. It was Friday, and everyone seemed to be in a good mood, from the people in the design center where they design all of the Tour staff golf bags (sadly, I couldn’t take any pictures here, but I can tell you that they’re working on some pretty cool prototype golf bags for the upcoming U.S. Open at Erin Hills in Wisconsin) to the marketing and multimedia departments. There we chatted with host and golf reporter Amanda Balionis and Harry Arnett the host of Callaway’s weekly variety show, Callaway Live. They couldn’t have been more gracious. Arnett has all of his guests sign a golf ball (or in the case of Hall of Fame pitcher Greg Maddux, a baseball) for the hallway trophy case. Here’s a video clip of Arnett explaining what the show is all about:     Jeff Neubarth is the Executive Producer of Callaway Media Productions and runs every Callaway Live show. I first met Jeff at the Golfsmith store in Scottsdale in early March of last year where I got fitted for a Callaway XR 16 driver by none other than Hank Haney. Jeff and his crew were on hand to document the experience, and ever since, I’ve been politely pestering Jeff for a copy of the video for my web site because I’d never seen it. I’d even gone so far as to follow-up with Jeff several months later to see if could get a DVD. He told me it was posted on Callaway’s Apple TV channel, but that was about as far as I could get. Then, when I ran into some more of Callaway’s big-wigs at the Epic Tour stop in December, I got some more contacts and emailed them my plight in hopes of getting their help but to no avail. What, Jeff has nothing better to do than to track down video clips for a small-time blogger? So flash forward… back to the Callaway offices. There we were, standing in the office where Jeff worked on a regular basis only to find out that he was in Austin for the week’s Dell Technologies Match Play. It also just so happened that one of Jeff’s co-workers, Associate Video Producer & Editor Alexis Eader, who was there on the day of the shoot, recognized me from the video having edited the piece herself, and told me she would be happy to email me a copy of the video. It also helped my cause that we were both Arizona State University Alums. You’ve gotta help a fellow Sun Devil whenever you can! I was thrilled! Finally, after more than a year of attempting to track it down, my quest to reunite with the video was complete. No matter what happened next, I was going to leave feeling satisfied. And the fitting was yet to come! The three of us milled about outside Research & Development hoping to gain access to the heart of Callaway Golf. Andrew’s security badge couldn’t

My Epic Experience Read More »

Todd Sones: The Finesse Sequence

Short game shots and scoring are really important in golf. That goes without saying. But what’s the difference between the greenside finesse sequence and the full swing power sequence? Your upper body leads the short game. Todd Sones is a Golf Digest Top 50 and Golf Magazine Top 100 Instructor who teaches out of White Deer Run Golf Club near Chicago. He also currently serves on the Golf Academy of America’s National Advisory Board. In this week’s tip (below), Todd demonstrates the finesse sequence. I transcribe these videos because they only stay up for about a week. You can always gain access to this tip and more by becoming an Impact Golf Member at toddsones.com: It’s a different sequence when you’ve got a greenside shot (as opposed to) a full swing shot. If you’ve got a full shot, you would start with your lower body. Your lower body starts down, then your upper body, and finally, your arms. You’re storing all the energy so at impact, everything releases. That’s a full power sequence. “Greenside, we call that a finesse sequence,” says Todd. “What that means is that when I take the club back, I don’t want to store all that energy and all that lag for impact. I’m trying to hit a softer greenside shot here with control of distance.” When the club goes back, instead of starting with your legs and storing all that lag, start down with your upper body and club together, not keeping any lag. Your legs should not start in your short game. When you go back and you start down, make sure the club is coming down in front of you. Your legs should be firm. They’re not driving. Then the club comes down in front of you, your upper body stays on top of the shot, and you compress the golf ball. The mistake so many people make is that they get to the top of the backswing for the shot they’re hitting and actually start with their legs. Their legs start, then the lower body runs out in front, and the upper body goes back. They skull the shot, or they hit it fat. So remember this: at the top of your backswing when you start down, keep your upper body on top and moving forward. A tip Todd always tells people is that at the end of a shot around the green, they should be able to do three things: lift their trail leg, fold their elbows, and pull the club into their body. If you start with your legs, you have to lift your forward leg because all of your weight’s back. Start with the upper body. You should be able to pick up your back foot, fold your elbows, and pull the club right into your belly button, and you’ll be great around the greens.    

Todd Sones: The Finesse Sequence Read More »

19th Annual Senior Member/Guest Tournament

La Paloma Country Club only closes the course completely three times a year: the Dove Hunt Member/Guest in November, the Senior Member/Guest in March, and the Ladies Member/Guest in April also know as Cazeria. These are the biggest events of our calendar year. The least stressful event that I’ve been a part of so far (and to be fair, there have only been two) has been the recently-completed Senior Member/Guest. The tournament is open to all golf members and their guests ages 55 years and older in 2017. The format is kind of cool too. It’s an Eclectic. In an Eclectic, the Net Best-Ball of each two-man team is recorded on each hole on the first day. On the second day, each player can improve his previous score on any or all of the holes from Day 1. The lowest 18-hole total of the Net Best-Ball on each hole over the two days will be the winner. For example, if the Net Best-Ball score on Hill No. 5 is a 7 on Day 1 and a 4 on Day 2, then the final score is a 4. If the Net Best-Ball score on Hill No. 6 is a 5 on Day 1 and a 6 on Day 2, then the final score will remain a 5. It basically gives the members and their partners a chance to improve on the same holes from one day to the next. Each team plays the same courses on Saturday as they did on Friday. There were 18 holes each day with a break for lunch in-between nines. This year’s two-day field featured 53 teams or 106 players. The Tournament Committee chose a country-western theme with each of the nine flights named after actors, outlaws, or famous cowboys from John Wayne and Butch Cassidy to Gene Autrey and Wyatt Earp. The winner of each flight was playing for commemorative belt buckles etched with the words “2017 La Paloma Senior Flight Winner.” I have to say, I’m not a huge country-western fan, but these belt buckles were sharp. The tournament came to an exciting conclusion with a sudden-death playoff from 151 yards out on Hill No. 9 to decide the Billy the Kid Flight. Hill No. 9 has always been a great spectator hole! When the lowest team total scores (no handicaps) couldn’t decide things after three holes, there was a chip-off from just off the green. With country-western music floating through the breeze in the background and a fairly good-sized gallery gathering on the hill overlooking the green, Greg Reihman’s partner Gerard Schmidtke chipped it to 10’11” to secure the win for his team. The two not only rode their matching FootJoy pink azalea golf shirts from Friday’s pre-tournament Concept Shop to victory, Schmidtke overcame a pretty serious illness on Day 1 to return to form on Day 2. While the Dove Hunt was way more exhausting, the Senior Member/Guest was definitely more fun and laid back. The weather was warm, the golf whether good or bad was played quickly, and everyone seemed genuinely happy to be out on the course for two really nice days of play.

19th Annual Senior Member/Guest Tournament Read More »

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Starting Reminders & Rulings

Dr. Robin Farran is one of the USGA’s top Rules Officials and teaches Advanced Rules at the Golf Academy of America in Phoenix. He’s always emailing out different Rules scenarios, which I am happy to re-post for our benefit! I call it Diary of a USGA Rules Official, and in this month’s installment, Dr. Farran has some not so subtle reminders about starting times and Decision 13-2/0.5: Starting Reminders In stroke play: 1. Player A has a starting time of 8:00AM. Player A arrives at the Starter’s Tent at 8:02AM, shortly after the first player in the group had been announced. Player A was listed 3rd on the starter’s sheet. **In the case where the fairway is clear and the Starter is ready to announce the players in the 8:00AM group, Player A incurs a two-stroke penalty. Player A must be present and ready to play as the assigned starting time. See the penalty statement under Rule 6-3a and Decision 6-3a/2. 2. Player B has a starting time of 8:10AM. Player B walks from the practice putting area to join his group at #1 tee arriving at 8:12AM. Several minutes later, as the fairway begins to clear, the Starter announces, “This is the 8:10 starting time, first to play is Player X”. Player B is listed as the 3rd player to start. **Player B does not incur a penalty. Player B was present and ready to play at the adjusted starting time for the 8:10AM group. The Starter was not able to maintain the schedule of starting times was due to the fairway not being clear. See Decision 6-3a/4.  In match play: 1. Single match, Player A vs Player B, is scheduled for 8:00AM. Player A is present and ready to play at 7:55AM. Player B arrives ready to play at 8:02AM. **In the case where the fairway is clear and the Starter is ready to announce the players in the 8:00AM match, Player B incurs a loss-of-hole penalty and the match continues at the 2nd hole. Player A is 1 up. See the penalty statement under Rule 6-3a. 2. Single match, Player C vs Player D, is scheduled for 8:10AM.  Player C is present at 8:05AM without his clubs which are on the cart shared with Player D. At 8:12AM, Player D arrives with the cart and equipment of both players. **Each player incurs a loss-of-hole penalty and the match commences on the 2nd hole. The 1st hole is deemed halved. See Rule 6-3a and Decision 6-3a/3. Interesting 1. Player A’s tee shot on a dogleg par-5 hole heads left as Player A attempts to cut the corner of the hole. The likely landing area slopes downward toward a bunker and a lateral water hazard. Player A, as he reached the area half-way to where his ball might be, decided to play a provisional ball. Rather than returning to the tee, Player A announced his intent to play a provisional ball, dropped and played a substituted ball from the fairway. Seeing the ball land with certainty in the lateral water hazard, Player A announced and played another provisional ball which landed in the fairway beyond the lateral water hazard. As Player A reaches the area where the original ball is likely to be, Player A decides that his original ball is likely to be in the lateral water hazard. Player A picks up the ball in the fairway and drops a ball under Rule 26-1b, estimating where the original ball entered the lateral water hazard. After the drop, Player A completed the hole in 4 additional strokes. ** Unless Player A corrected the serious breach from playing from a wrong place (not corrected in the real-life incident!), Player A is disqualified. Analysis of the Incident Details Several important concepts apply to this incident: 1) A player is not entitled to play a provisional ball from a position that is significantly nearer the hole than where the previous stroke was played, 2) A player is not permitted to play a provisional ball when it is known or virtually certain that the ball is in a lateral water hazard., 3) When a player proceeds under a Rule that is not applicable, the Committee must determine the Rule that does apply. See Rule 27-2a, Decision 27-2a/1.5 and Decision 34-3/6. Summary of Player A’s play of the hole: 7 physical/talent strokes plus 6 penalty strokes – 2 stroke-and distance-penalties, 1 two-stroke penalty for playing from a wrong place and 1 two-stroke penalty for lifting the ball in play and not replacing the ball (playing from a wrong place).  The Local Rule for 2017 is in effect for the following incident: 1. Player B grounds his putter closely behind his ball on the putting green and, as Player B begins his stroke, the ball starts to move and while the ball is in motion, Player B competes the stroke and holes the putt. **Player B is not penalized for causing his ball to move and is not penalized for playing a moving ball.  See the Local Rule for 2017 and Rule 14-5. Improving Decision 13-2/0.5 provides guidance for rulings in the following situations. It is necessary to determine prior to the player making a stroke whether the player has created a potential advantage by the changes to his/her lie, area of intended stance or swing or line of play. Consideration is given to the type of stroke, lie of the ball, distance to expected landing area, inherent difficulty of the stroke and degree of changes to the area protected by Rule 13-2. Some consideration would also be given to the capabilities of the player. [The ruling is not based on the outcome of the stroke by the player.] The player is a 10 handicap and weather conditions are calm and dry unless otherwise noted: 1. Player A’s ball lies in the fairway about 10 feet from the green and the flagstick is about 4 paces from the front of the green. Player A, putter in hand, while

Diary of a USGA Rules Official: Starting Reminders & Rulings Read More »